In the category of Best Saddle

We have:

• Brooks B17
  
• Brooks Swallow
  
• Brooks Team Professional
  
• Fizik Aliante
  
• Fizik Arione
  
• Lepper Voyager
  
• Selle Italia Flite
  
• Selle Italia Ladies Gel Flow
  
• Selle Italia SLR
  
• Selle Italia SLR C64
  
• Selle Italia SLR Carbonio
  
• Selle Italia SLR F1
  
• Selle Italia SLR XP
  
• Selle Italia Storika
  
• Selle Italia Turbo
  
• Selle San Marco Concor Supercorsa
  
• Selle San Marco Regal
  

In the category of Best Sadde

Tune Concorde

so where's the most popular saddle on track and road for the last decade or more: San Marco Rolls.

Brooks, hah! how they've gone from codgers to hipsters is an amazing bit of luck/marketing

Charge Spoon should be on that list. Its far more comfortable then my Fizik Arione and massively cheaper.

it's also made by charge, which means 80% of this forum owns one

Best saddle = arse concept.

I voted for the Storika cuz my bum made me.
But the SLR deserves rep for being universaly (to a point of course) comfy and lighter than half a dozen farts.

In the category of Best Sadde

Saddo. ;P

Fizik don't work for me at all, same as brooks. over rated arse chaffers.
this is a tough one, i might have to go lucky dip

Regals are amazing... That's all I have to say about that...

Hipstaaaaaaaaahhh

B33 ftw!

My preference is for a vintage Girardi Regal... Awesome...

my regal gave me bad saddle sores :( ive now resorted to heavily padded specialized from an old mountain bike - aesthetics have gone out the window for a comfortable ride.

I would have gone for the rolls but haven't experienced an Arione or Brooks

cinelli

Fizik Aliante, made a remarkable change for the better to my pedal stroke :)

Richard Sachs custom red Regal ftmfw!

Rolls.

Unica

selle italia girl's
Not big chance to win this one considering male-femal proportion, but, i swear on my bum, it works

Charge Spoon should be on that list. Its far more comfortable then my Fizik Arione and massively cheaper.

charge spoon gave me saddle sores and arione works for me.

each arse to its own, i guess

me too

Flite
Supercorsa
Brooks Professional
(In no particular order)
I haven't tried regals, other brooks', or a lot of the others on the list but don't get along with rolls or turbos at all.