Current Projects chat and miscellany

Is it not quite bad form to be that harsh in Current Projects? I'm not saying you can't give any -ive feedback, but shouldn't it be more along the lines of "not a fan of skinny forks on OS frames, it might look better with *x *instead of y, or;

If someone starts a thread just about there bike, then there's an acceptance of all comments welcome, but here? IMO current projects has a certain etiquette.

My hero. * le swoon *