It actually is very relevant, if you live in the real world. Police would not treat the above example equally would they, they would come down harder on the man who beats his wife 5x a week It's not completely fair, but that's the way it is, because police resources are not unlimited.. The police would make a call, which one poses a greater threat to the public.
Similarly you will face greater punishment if you are caught with 20g of Cocaine, than if you are caught with 1g. It's not so much excusing the criminal, as putting things in perspective.
Do you remember what it is we are questioning?
Woman A was beaten by Officer B, did Officer B act illegitimatly, or outside of the realms of action which those whom he serves would accept. discuss.
I don't see how it is relevant to bring into that question the fact that man C,D or E were beaten, raped or shot by Officers F,G and H in foreign lands.
Do you remember what it is we are questioning?
Woman A was beaten by Officer B, did Officer B act illegitimatly, or outside of the realms of action which those whom he serves would accept. discuss.
I don't see how it is relevant to bring into that question the fact that man C,D or E were beaten, raped or shot by Officers F,G and H in foreign lands.