You are reading a single comment by @Ben689908 and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • Yeah to be clear I’m probably more interested in keeping good relations with next door and reducing long-term cost than keeping the tree, but if there are options to do all 3 then great!

    As far as I can tell, they would have to prove definitely that any damage potentially caused by a tree is actually caused by it, and perhaps we might only be liable for any damage after they’ve actually informed us? I think they have the right to cut through the roots on their land too (similar to overhanging branches).

  • How close is the tree to the garage, and how big is the tree (height/canopy)?

    EDIT: now I have looked at further posts, and in particular the photo, I would be 90% certain that the tree is the problem.

  • Do we know that the problem/issue is? Just because a tree is close to something doesn't mean it can be blamed for issues with a building. Its the easy thing to assume (just because its there), so cut the tree down then realise its nothing do to with it...

    I would be asking what the issue is, evidence its being caused by your tree roots.

    @Pantsmaster - either way I would probs get someone to do some hard pruning on that and try and bring it back into shape.

  • I would be 90% certain that the tree is the problem.

    I would be 90% certain that the tree and garage can continue to co-exist in some shape or form. just depends on your point of view and priorities.

About

Avatar for Ben689908 @Ben689908 started