You are reading a single comment by @neu and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • In Ed's defense, they're really not, and I am in no way hearing impaired.

    For example, it just looks like continuous prose. There's no punctuation or 'Cole:' or 'Bill:'

    When there are close up shots of the watches, or whenever Cole/Bill's faces aren't on screen, you can't see their mouths moving to associate lip movements with the subtitles. So you have no idea who is speaking. Knowing Ed IRL, I know that he relies heavily on lip reading.

    A brand of Hodinkee's caliber not having subtitles is not excusable IMO - but that doesn't mean he should take it out on me every time I post a Hodinkee article 😂

  • Yeah, actually good captions need to be written, but we established that they don't exist already. For auto generated subs I thought they were pretty good actually.

  • Try and watch it without sound, you’ll find yourself struggling to follow it keeping your eyes glued to the bottom of the screen.

    The reason you find them acceptable is because you can hear them.

About

Avatar for neu @neu started