• His statement that white men are hated around the world and there is a lot of racism against whites people is hard to argue against

    Well it's certainly not my experience. I can't think of any time that, as a white man, I've felt myself the victim of racism, and I've travelled pretty far and wide in my time. OK, the secretaries in the Bangkok law firm where I spent 6 weeks doing work experience all claimed I looked like Elvis Presley, despite the fact I don't - apart from being white and having (in those days) black hair. Other than that - and I chalk that up as an amusing anecdote rather than a sign of racist oppression - I can't think of a single instance where I've felt that I've been treated in a negative way due to the colour of my skin.

  • I also think that people mistake racism for recognition of privilege. And then get offended by being called out on it.

    In a similar vein I remember choosing to walk around HCM city in Vietnam and being constantly accosted by taxi drivers because being white was a good signifier for being (relatively) wealthy, and so they assumed I would want a ride. It was annoying for me, but I could understand why they would do it.

    I can think of two acts that I think were genuinely racist, one also in Vietnam where my friend took me to see her Grandparents, who asked in ignorance if I bleached my arm hair (they had, as far as I know never seen someone with blonde arm hair), and a more recent stereotyping where a waiter in India repeatedly refused to serve me a dish because he was certain it was too hot (spicy) and I should order something else (I didn't and it wasn't).

    Both are so abnormal, that I could likewise laugh them off, and certainly don't make me think that I was hated for my skin colour.

  • Are either of those occurrences racism though? It depends on whether your definition is simply "being treated differently or with prejudice because of perceived ethnicity" or whether it also involves a power dynamic, underlying belief in superiority, or negative discrimination.
    I don't think the first instance is racism even with its mildest definition - if they never met anyone blond before then it's a fairly logical if slightly personal question. The second - sure it's based on stereotype and yes it was a form of discrimination although not particularly negative. The waiter maybe didn't want you to have a bad experience.

  • In a similar vein I remember choosing to walk around HCM city in Vietnam and being constantly accosted by taxi drivers because being white was a good signifier for being (relatively) wealthy, and so they assumed I would want a ride. It was annoying for me, but I could understand why they would do it.

    The same psychology is at play when a Cambridgeshire Police officer stops a driver for being black. In the cop’s mind, he’s just filtering for out-of-town individuals. You were profiled. Obviously the context is different and important.

  • I guess the point I was making was it's hard to argue against with out his lived experience.
    I'm not saying he thinking anti white racism is as big other types of racism.

About

Avatar for branwen @branwen started