The Mamnick Thread

I said earlier in the thread that people who abuse Muslims physically and verbally should pay for their actions. I've been clear on this. Horrendous.

You're ignoring the point of the article I cited which is that your politics is creating a climate whereby these people are emboldened to assault Muslims (primarily women, reflecting on the cowardice involved) and caveating your views with a disclaimer that you don't endorse violence doesn't change the fact that they are inciting it. Cause/effect, you are the company you keep...

What is your solution?

My solution is to let Muslim women say what they find acceptable, and for the UK to stop electing political parties that enable extreme political forces abroad as a matter of economic convenience, whether it is Thatcher supporting Pinochet whilst branding Mandela a terrorist, or her son trying to topple African governments for personal gain.

Mine is to open up the dialogue, spread the ideas and critique of the doctrine that lead to the subjection of women and gays. Help spread the ideas of people like Sarah Haider, Ayaan Hirsi Ali, Raheel Raza.

Your solution is to 'open up dialogue'? All you've done is mindlessly parrot a few people who are critical of Islam whilst calling people who disagree with you 'squids'-I can see no replies to any responses where you've been challenged about your explicit sexist, Anti Semitic actions? I think most of the people you quote would be embarrassed to be associated with you.

What is your solution then?

My solution is for you to recognise your own primary motivator is not noble, it's a twisted process of self-justification of prejudice that ignores the hypocrisy of attacking Islam for things like oppressing women but fails to recognise those women in the UK that are victims of violence and structural inequalities at the hands of the indigenous white population. If you're not equally outraged about this, it stands that your primary motivation is simply a dislike of Muslims.

So far you have obfuscated the critique by using the words 'islamophobe', 'racist' or suggested I'm a bigot / Tommy Robinson supporter or changed the subject to 'what about Christianity' ?

Your own twitter shows support for Tommy Robinson, whilst trying to mis-represent Nazis as Socialists. I've not used the term Islamaphobe, or racist, and I don't need to because it's readily transparent that you are, as well as an anti-semite.

I'm genuinely interested in your answer.

There you go.