Carradice Saddlebags

To elaborate on why I didn't like the SQR, I'll draw your attention to my post from this very thread some three years ago.

I've now ridden with the SQR and it's really annoying me, thinking of getting the QR support now at a painful £45. The bag still swings and it just looks saggy. I want it to look like a little sausage roll at the back but instead it looks like a cat hung up on a washing line by its shoulders. Admittedly it's carrying about 3.5kg which is the bag, support and contents.

I think I made the mistake of mixing a "classic" bag with a modern support. Or something. It just doesn't feel right.

I also seem to remember that it puts the top of the bag facing backwards so there's the constant risk of stuff falling out.