Which Clipless pedals?

I am fairly new to fixed riding but ride mtb's. i have been using some old egg beaters but have had some problems with them popping out. i have two pairs of riding shoes one with egg beaters cleats in and on road pair with look cleets in. I know quite a few people on here have had allot of luck with spd's but i don't want to have to keep swapping cleats in and out of shoes to ride different bikes.

So my question is, what are look pedals like for fixed riding? do they tend to pop out with too much up pressure?

cheers.

i ride lake shoes with SPD and they work fine for me.

For London I prefer Time, narrower drop, easier when near the curb un clipped.

+1 for time atac (well +2 really as I got them on 2 bikes)

Oh, hmmmm, I was thinking about changing over to eggbeaters. Are they not all that then?

The Majestic Bebop.

normally egg beaters would be fine but this set are quite worn so have become a bit lose.

curb clearance is not a problem as this gets ridden in the empty roads of the Yorkshire mores.

My choice is getting a new set of egg beaters or look keo's as i don't want to get a new set of shoes or swap cleats when using different bikes.

oblique - Get some premium eggbeater cleats - made of a harder material than those which come with the pedals and so last longer.

oblique - don't have looks but a set of time impact road pedals (very similar system to the looks). No problems at all with them, they work great on fixed.

However, check which cleat you have before forking out for a pair of keo pedals (if that's what you decide to do) - older look cleats and those for the newer keos look very similar but are incompatible (the keos are smaller, IIRC).

If you're riding road, I'd probably go with the looks, I've heard eggbeaters give you hotspots when riding for longer periods. Alternatively, virtually any road pedal cleat system will be compatible with your road shoes (you just unscrew the cleat and screw the new one in, and the cost of the cleat compared to the pedal is small, so you're not losing much by changing the cleat) so you're not constrained to just the looks. Again, I highly recommend Time road pedals! This guy knows his stuff: http://www.bikesportmichigan.com/features/rxspedals.shtml

Courant

i use look and haven't had any problems.

The combination that have the best review around here are MTB shoes with Time ATAC cleats and Time ATAC pedals. I initially started off on Road shoes with SPD-SL (like Look) cleats. I've heard that SPDs (the MTB ones) are easy to clip out because of the multi-release. Also egg-beaters are meant to be easy to clip out of (this is only a consideration if you're skidding). MTB shoes are easier to walk in but my road shoes and SPD-SLs seemed fine for float and clipping out. I never had premature de-cliption with my SPD-SLs. If you've already got road shoes and Look cleats/pedals I'd say just stick with them until you notice yourself clipping out too easily. If you don't. Don't change. If you do. MTB shoes and Time ATAC cleats are the best solution.

A

yeah yeah!
mtb shoes and time atacs all the way!

indeed!

If the eggbeaters are dead, you can probably pick up a set of time atacs and appropriate cleats for slightly less than a new set of eggbeaters would have cost.

look keo pedals/cleats are great on road bikes and there's no reason why they wouldn't be just as good on fixed. you don't generate any more upward pressure on a fixed than on a road bike...

so if you have Looks already on another of your bikes then stick with them EXCEPT if you want to walk in the shoes. if that's a consideration, maybe look at SPDs or Time aliums which are very popular here.

i ride SPDs on my fixed and have only ever pulled out a couple of times due to the pedal tension needing to be tightened (i'm a bit slack with maintenance).

I've only used SPDs and Eggbeaters, but my vote goes to the beaters because I find them easier (and much smoother) to clip out of, which is useful when some prick pedestrian steps out in front of you. That said, I don't go in for bunny hops and backflips.

I've got some egg beaters I pop out once a day. Its pain in the ass.

That said, I am using some homemade cleats....

@Will: Homemade cleats? How did you craft them?

if you make sure you have the eggbeater cleats the right way round on the shoes ( one way is easier to unclip, swap them round and it's harder), unclipping is not an issue, i reckon - as long as your cleats aren't worn.

I've heard that SPDs (the MTB ones) are easy to clip out because of the multi-release.

If people insist on using SPDs wrong then they'll not work.. first: don't use cleats with M-marking (M for multirelease), second: tighten down the tension screw at least a full turn, and third: make sure you have adjusted the angle of the cleat on your shoe so that you don't get to "clip out angle" without wanting to..

I have had 3 unclips i didn't want on my SPDs since starting using them, first was due to a wrongly adjusted cleat + too loose tension on the pedal (at least that's what i suspect), second was because a small stone stuck on the shoe by the cleat had blocked the cleat from being securely locked in, third i don't know, but i changed the pretty worn cleats and have not had problems since..

Skid all the time, run brakeless, and 48x17 gear, about 75 GI.

I use speedplay zeros on the roadbike, not popped out once in the 2 years I've used em. Lovely pedal cleat combo.

If people insist on using SPDs wrong then they'll not work.. first: don't use cleats with M-marking (M for multirelease), second: tighten down the tension screw at least a full turn, and third: make sure you have adjusted the angle of the cleat on your shoe so that you don't get to "clip out angle" without wanting to..

I have had 3 unclips i didn't want on my SPDs since starting using them, first was due to a wrongly adjusted cleat + too loose tension on the pedal (at least that's what i suspect), second was because a small stone stuck on the shoe by the cleat had blocked the cleat from being securely locked in, third i don't know, but i changed the pretty worn cleats and have not had problems since..

Skid all the time, run brakeless, and 48x17 gear, about 75 GI.

Thats great, but what shoes and clips are you using?

What I didn't mention is that once I've cycled to work, I walk around all day in them. So my cleats are worn to fuck.
I got some brass, then just cut out the same profile as the eggbeater cleats, they were fucking tight to start with, they have loosened up now.

I couldn't find a more appropriate thread and didn't want to start a new one, so.......

I saw a bike recently with interesting looking pedals. It looked like normal SPDs on one side, but the other side had a see-through flat plastic platform. Does anybody know what pedals these were? It looked like a good compromise for SPD clips and flat pedal riding (for non-cycle shoe use).

Not plastic, but Shimano do some single sided SPDs at least:

http://www.wiggle.co.uk/p/Cycle/7/Shimano_A530_SPD_Single_Sided_Touring_Pedals/5360031862/

They sound a bit awkward to me though? Dunno

Not the same one I saw. I think they might have been on a Cannondale, and maybe it was a road bike or a hybrid. A lot smaller and neater than the SPD pedal your highlighted. Thanks though...............the search continues.