Nope, neither of those are passing the "do they look good" test.
If you are trying to make a bike look good with mudguards you are missing the point, but you could use Salmon profile.
Better still go custom, I had a pair of guards made from Ti, using a hybrid of salmon and SKS fittings, but just a flat strip curved to follow the wheel. I had a mate at BAE do it, but he has since retired, but there must be plenty of people who could do it
If you get a few Salmon fittings and use the ones designed to hold the stays to the frame / forks in place of the naff eyebolt, and use SKS quick release on the forks, and make stays out of suitable stainless rod you could do a really neat job. Put some Rarpha stickers on, and there you go!
If you are trying to make a bike look good with mudguards you are missing the point, but you could use Salmon profile.
Better still go custom, I had a pair of guards made from Ti, using a hybrid of salmon and SKS fittings, but just a flat strip curved to follow the wheel. I had a mate at BAE do it, but he has since retired, but there must be plenty of people who could do it
If you get a few Salmon fittings and use the ones designed to hold the stays to the frame / forks in place of the naff eyebolt, and use SKS quick release on the forks, and make stays out of suitable stainless rod you could do a really neat job. Put some Rarpha stickers on, and there you go!