You are reading a single comment by @bq and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • Er, no. Plants are alive but not, in a philosophical sense, living. When an animal dies, it continues to live through the same micro-processes that plants do, but no-one would say it is still living.

    The substance of an animal is its life. Beyond that it is mere material.

    Plants are living organisms, with some level of sentient capacity, fulfilling all the criteria necessary to call them alive, such as respiration, movement, and crying out in pain when they are injured.
    Until you chop them to bits and cook them, of course.

    Philosophically, animals are only alive if you don't put them in a box with a radioactive isotope. If you do that who knows what state they are in?

About

Avatar for bq @bq started