Josh, I think the Smoky Islay was the Blackadder bottle and I believe it is a blend of various Islay whiskies.
The ones that stood out for me were:
Laphroaig 18 yr - Laphroaigy yet very smooth.
Caol Ila 30 yr, Independent bottling, don't remember which - Very nice, smooth and smoky
Great seeing you guys and we should do another one soon.
Laphroaig is what got me in to nice whiskey.. Well that and Makers Mark ;)
Laphroaig is what got me in to nice whiskey.. Well that and Makers Mark ;)