Stone Roses

Just been told by Rob da Bank that the Stone Roses are reforming for a summer tour

Can anyone confirm this or is robby lying?

Its front page of the Guardian (website). He could never sing anyway!

Shit the bed

http://www.guardian.co.uk/music/2009/mar/17/stone-roses-reunion-reported

They were generally shit live btw.

there's a cracking youtube clip of them at the hacienda, where it sounds more metal than byrds.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/music/2009/mar/17/stone-roses-reunion-reported

They were generally shit live btw.

Seen them live a few times. Great times

Ian Brown has improved alot since going solo.

I saw them 3 or 4 times too. I love them still but think they were more of a studio band than a live band.

I'd still go and see them again mind.

Saw 'em at Spike Island - it were alright.

Saw them twice, they were great. Not sure if them getting together is a good idea. Clearly thinking of the cash.

they were talking about this on the Radcliffe-Maconie show last night on R2 (yes I'm an old man), and apparently it's on. would make my year if it happens.

Brownie has denied the reunion is back on apparently

Hope Ian B sticks to his guns, personally. I hate encores.

Comebacks are like drum solos. Shit.

bump

http://www.guardian.co.uk/music/2011/oct/17/stone-roses-ian-brown-john-squire?newsfeed=true

Hope Ian B sticks to his guns, personally. I hate encores.

Comebacks are like drum solos. Shit.

^This.

^This.

Not necessarily true, both Pixies and The Specials have reformed in the last few years for live gigs if not new material. They've both been great and given people who didn't see them originally a chance to do so.

The Stone Roses were always wank live.

don't tell a Mancunian the stone roses were over-rated

it's like arguing Beatles all over again

I'll disagree. Musically wank, possibly, but two of the best gigs I've ever been to. The atmosphere at both was tremendous.

Not necessarily true, both Pixies and The Specials have reformed in the last few years for live gigs if not new material. They've both been great and given people who didn't see them originally a chance to do so.

The Stone Roses were always wank live.

don't tell a Mancunian the stone roses were over-rated

it's like arguing Beatles all over again

O rly?

Ya Rly

the pixies and the specials really have something,

Stone Roses are just a bunch of big headed Mancs who have ideas above there station. i'd listen to Oasis before i'd listen to Stone Roses and i hate Oasis,

Ya Rly

the pixies and the specials really have something,

Stone Roses are just a bunch of big headed Mancs who have ideas above there station. i'd listen to Oasis before i'd listen to Stone Roses and i hate Oasis,

Correct, as Andy W says it was all about atmosphere. An atmosphere created by a load of professional mancunian wankers (90% of any Stone Roses audience would've been made up by people from Salford and Ireland).

Pints of wine at Spike Island.

They better bring Cressa......it won't be a reunion without Cressa. Anyway, I'm in - full on rose tints - don't care, was always about the vibe, I'm gonna chuck a cheeky half down me neck and make like it's 1989.....

Stone Roses
The Beatles
Rob Da Bank
Oasis

All wank! >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Not necessarily true, both Pixies and The Specials have reformed in the last few years for live gigs if not new material. They've both been great and given people who didn't see them originally a chance to do so.

The Stone Roses were always wank live.

Going to see The Specials in a couple weeks. Can't wait.

#daddancing