You are reading a single comment by @tynan and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • You're response seems to be pointing to this: If B is not happy when "this happens," then they should be C.

    No, I've not said anything even remotely like that.

    "What I am saying" (I got that line off Tony Blair) is that I don't recognise the comparison between an 18k hypothetical tax that is immediately payable and presumably mandatory and presumably without obvious consideration/return/reward . . .

    . . . with a tuition fee that ultimately is optional, pays for a college education of your choice, in most cases leads to higher earnings and can be paid off in a way that makes it affordable to everyone.

    Going back to your original point - if we forcibly imposed a 18k tax of some kind we'd see a whole lot more people on the streets - I can't see how this (out hypothetical 18k tax) is comparable to the tuition fees, the dynamic of the two are so completely different.

About

Avatar for tynan @tynan started