Crud Road Racer vs SKS Chromoplastic

I am thinking to add some mudguards to my tight clearance Langster with 700*25 Marathon Plus tires.

Do you think that CrudRoadRacer MK2 is best option or if I can trim a bit the SKS Chromoplastic would be better?

Search is your friend http://www.lfgss.com/thread51033.html

Sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks

sks. crud's are brittle. end thread.

Sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks sks

This.

And some.

Chromoplastics without question. The Roadracers are a nightmare to fit and they just sort of go wherever they please - I had no end of rubbing with mine. The Chromoplastics took a little bit of bending but eventually I got them where I wanted them and they stayed there, mostly. The only real problem I had with them is how closely they fit - when snow gets packed in there, it can get hard to pedal due to the resistance.

I have chromoplastics on the beater. (Except for winter when I need the clearance and run traditional crud catchers).

Three things stand out for me:

• Once fitted well I dont get too much toe overlap, as you can adjust the back of the front close to the tyre. (true of a lot of mudguards).

• On less than perfect roads, with either hard road tyres or knobbly CX tyres, they do not move about or make noise.

• When I take them off road, and crash alot (I should take them off, but dont always). I always seem to be able to bend them back into place.