Worth upgrading low cost MTB pedals?

Posted on
  • I have been using shimano M520 MTB pedals for commuting for a few years and whilst I would like to stick with MTB shoes I was wondering if I am missing out on anything by sticking with these low end pedals?

    The XT M770’s seem to be quite a bit more expensive and I note that other manufactures also do more costly alternatives to my old M520’s, what do you get for the extra money?

  • You mainly save weight. So unless you go for a different system, its not worth the extra money for commuting alone TBH.

    Personally I like stainless steel bits on my commuting pedals, for longevity. Which pushes me to slightly higher end versions of the pedals I have commuted in.

  • If you need to buy a new pair of shoes then reconsider. I much prefer the stiffness of road shoes even on a commute. Pedals can be had pretty cheaply anyways. I ride some old, perfectly fine dura ace ones I got for 30 quid.

  • Mine are going quite rusty where the chrome has come off, so apart from cosmetics, they do the job.

    With regard to swaping over to road pedals I can understand that the bigger platform might be a good thing and I thought about changing to the speedplay system, (for the float) but when I saw the cleat I could see me doing a bit of skating at the lights.

  • Mine are going quite rusty where the chrome has come off, so apart from cosmetics, they do the job.

    With regard to swaping over to road pedals I can understand that the bigger platform might be a good thing and I thought about changing to the speedplay system, (for the float) but when I saw the cleat I could see me doing a bit of skating at the lights.

    I commute in BeBops (similar system to Speedplay). double sided like a SPD, free float like speedplays, and a nice big platform.

    The cleats stick out though, but you get used to that (unless you need to walk far).

  • there are always café covers...

  • I have been using shimano M520 MTB pedals for commuting for a few years and whilst I would like to stick with MTB shoes I was wondering if I am missing out on anything by sticking with these low end pedals?

    The XT M770’s seem to be quite a bit more expensive and I note that other manufactures also do more costly alternatives to my old M520’s, what do you get for the extra money?

    I could send you my Time Atac XS's for Gbp 40 incl postage; you'd have to get some Time cleats then. PM me if you're interested.

  • m520's are fine, if you have the cash upgrade.

  • is the float significantly better on a higher spec shimano spd like the xt ones? I find that the m520's float a bit grindy and not very floaty

  • I've got xtr's on my road bike and put some M520's on the commuter as they were only £13 new off eBay and the old DX SPD's were finally dying (15 years+). I have to say purely holding them I could not tell the difference in weight (disappointing as the xtr's were c.£80). As for float the M520's seem to have a lot compared to the xtr's or the old DX's.

  • I used a few 520s over the years. They are good, durable, cheap. I never saw a reason to use a higher spec. SPDs.

  • Post a reply
    • Bold
    • Italics
    • Link
    • Image
    • List
    • Quote
    • code
    • Preview
About

Worth upgrading low cost MTB pedals?

Posted by Avatar for Runoutofgears @Runoutofgears

Actions