I always set the saddle height so that my leg is at full extension/dead straight with my heel on the pedal- is this not the hard and fast rule that I had supposed it to be?
it's more of a very basic rule of thumb actually, because your shoe/pedal type and foot length make a difference.
also, track riders* tend to have a slightly lower saddle than mtb'ers and roadies, to facilitate smooth pedaling whilst seated at high cadences.
You shouldn't ever have a "locked" out leg, this causes your hips to be pulled into the pedal stroke and rock, which in turn upsets the balance of your core which contributes to the bouncing
it's more of a very basic rule of thumb actually, because your shoe/pedal type and foot length make a difference.
also, track riders* tend to have a slightly lower saddle than mtb'ers and roadies, to facilitate smooth pedaling whilst seated at high cadences.
You shouldn't ever have a "locked" out leg, this causes your hips to be pulled into the pedal stroke and rock, which in turn upsets the balance of your core which contributes to the bouncing
*I include any fixed wheel rider for this example