Brooks

i have a rolls on one bike and that's instantly been comfy and a brooks 17 narrow on the other - still a pain in the ass 10 months on (but getting better). I have high expectation for the brooks in the long term though

I found the rolls to be a lots more uncomfortable than the previous saddle (B-17), perhaps it's personal preference?

I just want a comfy race saddle, I've tried LOTS, but not those two

Everyone kept saying how comfortable the Rolls is, I end up buying one and turn out to be really uncomfortable (but not sore), so now I take everyone's advice with tonnes of salt.