Chain checkers like that aren't super accurate anyway, because they have to include a fudge factor for roller slop.
To measure actual elongation, hold the chain tight with the crank and hold a ruler with the 0 at the centre of a pin, and look at 254mm. How far away from 254mm is the next pin? Work out how many more percent it is, say 255.5/254 = 100.59%.
If it's more than half a percent longer, change the chain. If it's more than 0.75% longer, you probably need a new cassette too. If you let it get too far, it'll then start to chew up your rings.
Chain checkers like that aren't super accurate anyway, because they have to include a fudge factor for roller slop.
To measure actual elongation, hold the chain tight with the crank and hold a ruler with the 0 at the centre of a pin, and look at 254mm. How far away from 254mm is the next pin? Work out how many more percent it is, say 255.5/254 = 100.59%.
If it's more than half a percent longer, change the chain. If it's more than 0.75% longer, you probably need a new cassette too. If you let it get too far, it'll then start to chew up your rings.