• In keeping with the title I'm going to leave this here....

    We used data about the same people included in the study by Feleke et
    al. but this time, Public Health England provided us with the
    ‘secondary’ cause of death: the external ICD-10 codes provided
    information on the cause of the event; these secondary causes were
    what the medical consequences were, i.e. the medical reason they died.

    Even when we combined six years of data and large age-groups, numbers
    were small so we grouped the causes of death into head injury,
    multiple injury, and other.

    Using the raw numbers, we found that four times as many drivers and
    five times as many pedestrians died from a head injury as cyclists.
    Although a higher proportion of cyclists died from a head injury, this
    represented 46% of fatal injuries in cyclists and 42% in pedestrians;
    most pedestrians and drivers died of ‘multiple injuries’ which is not
    coded as the separate injuries themselves.

    When we used NTS data as a measure of exposure in people aged 17+ (the
    legal limit for driving), we found that fatal head injury rates in men
    were 11/bnkm for cyclists, 23/bnkm for pedestrians and 0.7/bnkm for
    drivers and 9, 10 and 0.4/bnkm respectively for women.

    Using National Travel Survey data has enabled us to combine data on
    road travel deaths with an accurate measure of exposure – how much
    people of different ages and gender travel by the different modes.

  • Think when you're looking at fatalities that's a very small proportion of bike accidents, and statistically far more likely to involve cars. Reckon the stats look very different if you're considering risk of injury more generally, so I think the HES data quoted by Sustrans is a better set to be considering if the concern is injury prevention. Probably wouldn't argue a helmet would make much of a difference in a crash where a car plows into you regardless of whether you're a cyclist or a pedestrian, but think it might help if you're plowing into a car that's cut you off/turned across you..

About

Avatar for spacey @spacey started