-
I've no experience of those brands, all I can say is I like Barker for English made shoes at a reasonable(ish) price and Meermin are well worth looking at for high quality Goodyear welted shoes at a slightly lower price (made in China, but you'd be hard pushed to tell the difference to Barkers and I'd say probably preferable to Loakes).
-
I’d also take a look at Loake as I’ve had a few pairs and they’ve held up well… Sanders would be my second choice as they’ve been around for a very long time and the suede/crepe shoes I’ve had from them were good quality…
Would you consider Derby’s? I’d be tempted to try the Horatio copies of JM Weston - https://www.horatio-london.com/products/norfolk-derby-black-calf
It’s time to buy a pair of black Oxfords, entry level Goodyear welts c. £200-250.
I’ve found a few shoe brands which have a similar offering;
Sanders
Berwick
Herrings
Without buying a pile of shoes to be delivered, are there any quality factors to account for on the best brand from the hive mind?