You are reading a single comment by @Prole. and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • Quite, so kill every firstborn before they come after me?

    This cannot be the will of the Jewish diaspora, I count some amongst my friends and loved and lost one of them. Neither can it be what the Israeli people want as most of them must be sane.

  • Quite, so kill every firstborn before they come after me?

    This cannot be the will of the Jewish diaspora

    I'd edit this if I were you.

    The 'will of the Jewish diaspora' isn't some monolithic world view. Particularly in the US Jews have been leading the protests against Israel's attacks on Gaza and there has been a Jewish bloc at the London demonstrations for example. Jewish opposition to Zionism has always existed and Jews play a prominent role today in criticising the political ideology of Zionism and the actions of the state of Israel.

  • I think it’s ok. I read it as being: it’s nonsense to say ‘extreme statement x is the will of the diaspora’.

    Just as it was nonsense to say x is the will of Palestinians in the Gaza Strip (on the last page).

    I understand how it could be read differently though (so perhaps worth an edit anyway).

About

Avatar for Prole. @Prole. started