You are reading a single comment by @andyfallsoff and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • I've seen criticism of that link that starting in 2008 misses the last major set of killings by Hamas during the Second Intifada (2000-2005) although I believe the overall impression remains broadly the same.

    Edit: from Wikipedia;

    Casualties and losses
    29 September 2000 – 1 January 2005:

    • 644–773 Israeli civilians killed by Palestinians;
    • 215–301 Israeli security force personnel killed by Palestinians

    • 2,739–3,168 Palestinians killed by Israel's security forces;*

    • 34 Palestinians killed by Israeli civilians

  • These numbers aren't nothing are they?

    I agree Israel goes too far in its responses and there are clearly examples of behaviour by Israeli security services which are completely unacceptable. But it's also fair to say they are in a difficult position - there are significant numbers of people in Palestine who will attack Israel and seek to kill civilians. They can't do nothing. For those who paint Israel (the govt) as the clear villain, what exactly do you think they should do without putting their citizens at risk?

    Clearly (to most outsiders at least) the end destination should be some form of the two state solution, but Israel will never disarm (it's a sovereign state and given the history of persecution against Jews, and the very real existence of many who don't accept its right to exist) that's probably reasonable. So Palestine won't entirely disarm either... How do you actually get to a peaceful settlement?

    I just don't believe that "well if Israel stopped what it was doing to Palestine there would be no problem" is likely - even ignoring the real difficulties of getting Israelis to trust in it, where hundreds of years of history tells them that there will always be people who want to eradicate Jews altogether.

  • For those who paint Israel (the govt) as the clear villain, what exactly do you think they should do without putting their citizens at risk?

    Focus on defending it's own territory and not constantly allowing illegal settlements in Palestinian territoy?

About