You are reading a single comment by @E11_FTW and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • The alternative/conspiracy version would be that Netanyahu is anomalous in recent terms in being an Israeli leader facing a precarious political mandate and popular dissent and protest at home, for whom an all out war against Hamas/Iran would be politically advantageous in the short/medium term.

    I can't fathom that this could be true, that a leader would purposefully allow this to happen to his people and the people in Gaza.

    I think Netanyahu has blood on his hand recent and previously stirring up the extremists for his political gain and survival.

    Put very well by Simon Tisdall in the guardian
    https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/oct/09/war-netanyahu-liability-must-go-israel-palestine-hamas

  • Hmm, I don't know. Isn't history absolutely littered with leaders who have developed an ability to psychologically hand-wave away thousands or even millions of deaths on both their side and the enemy's? Industrial-scale war could barely exist without this phenomenon, no?

    Just to take two examples, Henry Kissinger's deliberate prolonging of the Vietnam war and George W Bush's determination to complete his father's 'unfinished business' in Iraq. Both condemned thousands to death on both sides of each conflict.

    In Kissinger's own words, these are "men able to create their own reality", and my (under-informed) intuition tells me Netanyahu is in this mould.

  • Industrial-scale war could barely exist without this phenomenon, no?

    On reflection you have a point.
    In fact the canon fodder for (almost) every war has always been the people least likely to benefit from its spoils.

  • Both condemned thousands to death on both sides of each conflict.

    I think the latest best guess is a total death toll for Iraq/Afghan of 750k humans. Directly. Indirect deaths will surely take this number over 1M

    Not nit-picking. But there is some gravity to the size of the number that is not appreciated when it is so poorly reported.

About

Avatar for E11_FTW @E11_FTW started