You are reading a single comment by @Sumo and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • I'm not usually prone to conspiracy theories (I think!) but the fact that I have an intuitive feeling about all this that I can't see reflected in the 'mainstream media' makes me feel that I might have unconsciously fallen into conspiracy/irrational thinking and could do with a sense check.

    The narrative seems to be that this was an unprecedented and historical 'failure' of Israeli intelligence, who would normally provide pre-warning of attacks from Palestine/the occupied territories. The alternative/conspiracy version would be that Netanyahu is anomalous in recent terms in being an Israeli leader facing a precariouspolitical mandate and popular dissent and protest at home, for whom an all out war against Hamas/Iran would be politically advantageous in the short/medium term.

    Is considering the idea that Israeli intelligence DID know about the planning of this offensive but calculated that it would ultimately be beneficial basically doing an anti-semitism, or is it in the realm of possibility?

About

Avatar for Sumo @Sumo started