You are reading a single comment by @itsbruce and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • Less enamoured of the society parts, which are a bit Russian Downton Abbey.

    Nah.... Tolstoy wrote this as someone highly critical of his contemporaries. Julian Fellows creams his pants whenever he sees a signet ring.

  • Tolstoy wrote this as someone highly critical of his contemporaries.

    Up to a point and the Fellowes comparison is inaccurate, but it's all narrated from the PoV of patricians. Platon Karatev is the most prominent prole by far, most other non-nobs being background ciphers with brief appearances, and even he is entirely reported as observed by Pierre. It's not Downton Abbey but it never comes within shooting distance of Gosford Park. I just got tired of that perspective.

  • Yeah, fair enough. If I recall correctly, the closest Tolstoy gets to the lower classes is giving voice to a huntsman. He really had no clue what the lives of the help were like.

  • I kinda like the society bits, tbh. Pretty reflective of the time, when anyone below a certain level simply did not exist in any meaningful sense. It's early days, though. I'm only halfway through part two.

About

Avatar for itsbruce @itsbruce started