You are reading a single comment by @Peter_Carter and its replies.
Click here to read the full conversation.
-
I ve seen him criticised for cherry picking data but nothing yet that says he's wrong and then uses data and science to challenge him.
It's also suggested that he relies too much on activist data and science, ie work that's more likely than not to support his polemic.
Now back to the book.
Peter_Carter-
Sarah Langford is quite a public critic of Monbiot, and specifically regenesis. Don’t know enough about her stuff to know if she’s kosher but she’s not advocating for industrialised farming. If you’re interested in balance she maybe worth looking out.
One scientist I know called him out on Twitter on something he’d got wrong and he was good enough to come meet her and her colleagues to chat about it.
Tonts
I have this bookmarked to read as a counter argument when I finish it.
https://smallfarmfuture.org.uk/?p=1978
The book has upset a lot of farmers on twitter but haven't seen many refute the arguments robustly.