I have had a pair of Terrex for a couple of years at least, still going strong although definitely marked up significantly from my pedals (flats). I have the goretex versions as well which are genuinely waterproof.
However they’re not warm (although I really suffer with cold extremities in winter), they’re actually so resistant to ventilation that chemical foot warmers don’t heat up inside them- using conventional shoes inside Endura flat-pedal overshoes with the same chemical warmers is much better from a warm and dry perspective.
Criticism would be that they’re very flexible- you might want a stiffer sole.
I have had a pair of Terrex for a couple of years at least, still going strong although definitely marked up significantly from my pedals (flats). I have the goretex versions as well which are genuinely waterproof.
However they’re not warm (although I really suffer with cold extremities in winter), they’re actually so resistant to ventilation that chemical foot warmers don’t heat up inside them- using conventional shoes inside Endura flat-pedal overshoes with the same chemical warmers is much better from a warm and dry perspective.
Criticism would be that they’re very flexible- you might want a stiffer sole.