You are reading a single comment by @andyfallsoff and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • Going back to the whole cost of living crisis and nationalising essential services. Surely wholesale gas prices are only an issue for countries that don't have any gas supplies themselves.

    But in the UK the North Sea produces more natural gas than we actually use. The issue is that private companies are extracting the UK's gas, then selling them to the highest bidder on the international market. If the government were to take back control of their own gas supplies, they could supply all of the UK's gas at cost price.

    Is this a gross simplification?

  • They've already sold the rights to extract gas so would have to go back on that to do this, and would then need the expertise / machinery to extract it (and would be unlikely to get help from oil companies who have just been burnt by govt).

    UK international reputation hurt for failing to honour contracts, lack of actual ability to get stuff out.

    So it could have worked if we'd planned better from the start but the issue was in starting the "sell it to oil co" plan in the first place.

    Arguably they could still tax them more and then use that money to fund rebates for consumers- that's more or less the lab plan now I think

  • Yep, they would need to compensate the companies who currently own those licenses. It's certainly possible. Labour are planning on giving those same companies ~£29 billion in order to set the price cap at current levels. How much more to buy back the licenses?

    The expertise would be a lot of the same people and service providers already working for those current companies. They would just be taken on by UK Gas co.

    And as for the UK's reputation ... well, not sure that is such a huge issue anymore.

    I guess I'm just saying it's still possible.

About