You are reading a single comment by @Bobbo and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • Already blocked Russia...

    Visitors in the last month (determined by unique IP address).

    It bugs me that 492 IPs are mapped to Russia, but that's a bug in MaxMind GeoIP lookup as I did look at the POPs that the traffic originated and it was all Frankfurt.

    So the block has been effective for all of the last 30 days.

  • I'm guessing that the dots aren't a true geographical representation of the actual location of the IP addresses (I'm not too good at information or technology). I can guarantee that no one who lives where the dot is in Aus goes outside when the fucking suns up let alone rides a sweet fixeh when the suns up or for 6 hours before of after its in the sky.

  • I'm guessing that the dots aren't a true geographical representation of the actual location of the IP addresses

    Correct.

    IP addresses don't really have a location, but there are companies like MaxMind who attempt to imply a location based on where traffic from the IP appears on the internet, i.e. London has a major internet exchange and if an IP is seen always appearing in London there's a reasonable certainty that the IP address is located in London.

    However it's also total bollocks, because the MaxMind database isn't complete and only refreshes on a monthly basis and IPs can transfer ownership and they are constantly being moved around. And then there's weird things, like Marseille... Marseille is a place where a lot of undersea internet cables surface and so Chinese traffic may first appear on the internet at Marseille... with the result that MaxMind makes a lot of errors in their geographical attribution of IP addresses.

    It's a solution that at best is mere "an approximate guess of where this IP may be".

    A far better solution is to rely on Anycast networking, this at least reveals where an IP is based on the network topology... it's not going to be accurate down to a city, but it's going to be more accurate based on a region or country.

    I'm meh about all of this, cute maps are cute but there's not a lot of value in them.

About

Avatar for Bobbo @Bobbo started