Get the top one welded roughly for the full punk wabi look! I did that to a little LeCreuset pot when the handle broke off when I dropped it onto a stone flagged floor.
In fairness to the Global and John Lewis they replaced both of them for me. Although the Lady at JL was baffled by the smaller broken knife, which she could not find on their assortment. Days later it transpires we didn't actually buy that knife there, they replaced it with an alternative anyway.
Get the top one welded roughly for the full punk wabi look! I did that to a little LeCreuset pot when the handle broke off when I dropped it onto a stone flagged floor.