• @Trunkie This is frustrating because to me there seems to be no reason why you can't just stick a suitable beam in there without columns. Possibly because the resultant brick pier on the outside corner might not be sufficient to take the load? Or possibly the work take you within 100mm of the party wall and he wants to spare you needing an award?

    I've counted bricks to guessimate the width of the offshoot as 3m, so with a new opening width @ 2.6 it might be one of these things.

    Phone him up and ask why the beam can't sit directly on the masonry, and ask if it's one of the above, he'll probably not like being questioned, but it's his own fault for not giving better advice.

    DW about BC - you can always re-submit the SE calcs before/after the work is done. Only a small job.

  • Thanks. We're having a 450mm pier on the party wall side, not a column, so no need for an agreement. I wondered if the column is needed on the return side to give the return wall something substantial to tie to?

    I'll speak to him but I imagine all the overpeccing is purely to cover his back in the event of the worst.

  • I imagine that's probably it. Quite a lot of load coming down directly on the corner. Might be worth seeing how much smaller you'd have to make the window before you could omit the column. If its 100 - 150mm you might decide it's worth it.

About

Avatar for Trunkie @Trunkie started