You are reading a single comment by @William. and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • EVs will do little to improve urban air quality, as most of the harmful particulates that cause cancer, Alzheimers, respiratory disease and cardiovascular disease come from the brakes and tyres.

    Particulate emissions are only one category of harmful emissions. You've chosen a very funny way of saying "EVs completely eliminate harmful gaseous emissions such as NOx and carbon monoxide and sulphur dioxide and significantly reduce particulate emissions."

    Interestingly it looks to me like the main reason tyre and brake wear have become such a significant proportion of emissions is that exhausts contain a lot less particulates than they did 20 years ago (graph on page 25).

    https://uk-air.defra.gov.uk/assets/documents/reports/cat09/1907101151_20190709_Non_Exhaust_Emissions_typeset_Final.pdf

    (also that report seems to derive a lot of its numbers from some very speculative modelling and only small scale real world evidence)

  • Particulate emissions are only one category of harmful emissions. You've chosen a very funny way of saying "EVs completely eliminate harmful gaseous emissions such as NOx and carbon monoxide and sulphur dioxide and significantly reduce particulate emissions."

    Interestingly it looks to me like the main reason tyre and brake wear have become such a significant proportion of emissions is that exhausts contain a lot less particulates than they did 20 years ago (graph on page 25).

    This data is positive. Also a big plus is the reduction in engine noise.

About

Avatar for William. @William. started