• You're taking a quite extreme example there to make your point. Obviously taking down systems that massively unfairly benefitted one group over another is disadvantageous to that group in power. The same argument for taking slaves away from slave owners. But the point is, affording the same rights to all women (AFAB or trans), does not mean taking rights away from AFAB women. Just in the way that making sure Black people aren't unfairly treated doesn't mean that white people need to start being unfairly treated.

  • Sure it's an extreme eg. But if you give it some thought there will be plenty of other instances, big and small where the dominant culture is giving something up.

    Overall having a fairer more equitable society is good from a moral pov, and hopefully gives the society the best shot at utilising all its resources.

  • But if you give it some thought there will be plenty of other instances, big and small where the dominant culture is giving something up.

    I actually can't think of anything in the case of trans rights and also don't see the point of this (weird) line of thinking.

About

Avatar for hugo7 @hugo7 started