-
• #52
Couple of things.
Your price sounds off...
Have you checked your DXF sizing? DXF files are unitless, they are essentially just a set of lines that the software follows. make sure before you export them they're in mm as that's what fractory use.The bit which has the arrow pointing to it is where all the flex is going to come from. The extrusion is by design quite stiff (high second moment of area). this means you'll get the best results using that stiffness to your advantage. A plate has quite a low second moment of area which means it'll be flexy.
If you can mount the upright beam across the full width of the steel plate it'll support the plate and stop it flexing and you'll get a stiffer jig.
1 Attachment
-
• #53
re:pricing.
- 20%tax + post
- 20%tax + post
-
• #54
I was surprised too, cheaper even as I had 12 of the big ones and 6 of the small ones first. Dimensions are definitely in the right ballpark. Good points re: the design, I just drew the bare minimum and slapped a fillet on it. Was thinking of triangles like this, but my sketch blew up when I did that and I didn't think it'd make a difference for pricing.
2 Attachments
-
• #55
The arrow was supposed to be pointing to the airgap between the two bits of extrusion where all the load will be transferred through two thin plates. I lack paint skills.
You want the bits of extrusion to clamp to each other face to face not cantilevered up on thin plates.
Re:price
You don't need S355, fixtures need stiffness not strength. Better steel gets you a better yield strength but the stiffness will be the same.That price will go down if you add more bits. Small orders are priced WAAY higher to account for set up and office time.
-
• #56
You want the bits of extrusion to clamp to each other face to face not cantilevered up on thin plates.
But then it can't rotate? Am I missing something very obvious? The angle of that beam needs to be adjustable.
I could do 3mm CR4 instead but it saves 5 quid on the entire order so figured I'd go for 4mm.
-
• #57
orange = main beam
green = upright
red = anchor points to uprightThe upright is anchored across the full width of the plate so that the stifness comes from the cross-section of the extrusion rather than relying on the cross-section of the plate. See how the upright goes across all of the metal plate?
The same thing is happening with the main beam so the extrusions end up mating face to face. (with the plate acting kinda like a big washer)
-
• #59
Aha! Your previous comments make a lot more sense now. Should have room for that, I’ll give it a go this weekend.
-
• #60
Oh meant to say previous not precious. 👆
I think this is better in some ways but worse in others, particularly in terms of clearance around the NDS bottom bracket. Maybe not the best avenue to go down?
1 Attachment
-
• #61
Small orders are priced WAAY higher to account for set up and office time.
This line of thinking had me painting 50 bookends a while ago. And deburring a lot of clamps because I forgot to tick the box. With the company I use here 1 piece tends to be about as expensive as 5 and then 25 is about double the price of 1.
2 Attachments
-
• #62
sweet clamps. group buy? were they all snapped up?
-
• #63
Yep, all gone. Was a bit hush hush as I felt bad about stealing Cobra's design. Initially planned on doing just 3 as a thank your for a friend. Happy to send you the files, these were 12mm alu.
-
• #65
I made a laser aligner that clamps around the BB-shell. Here's it being aligned on the mill-bed before then being mounted to the jig to align that.
The DIY framejig is now straight as an arrow.
I'm thinking about making a batch of these, anyone interested?
the only photo i have of the framejig being aligned.
-
• #66
That’s neat. How much would it be
-
• #67
Could also be interested.
-
• #68
Built, mounted on a dummy BB (68 or 73) with a laser fitted and aligned I'd be looking for £75.
If you have access to a resin printer I'm happy enough to share a step/stl file. Just throw some money into my paypal to cover buying some fancy coffee (my main vice after power tools).
The tolerances and shrinkage rates have been figured out for elegoo abs-like resin so if you use something different you may have to do some scalings and test-prints to get it running.
-
• #69
-
• #70
Anyone know of any European supplier of dummy axles for my homemade jig? I'm in Dublin and trying to avoid having to pay Brexit duties by buying them from TBA as I already got charged once for some parts.
-
• #71
-
• #72
Hey, did you make the angle back plates yourself or buy them? I'm trying to find something similar for my jig as I've got the ideas2cycle pucks.
Thanks
Dan -
• #73
Nope, my own design. I have three more sat here doing nothing in a 12mm thick version I can sell ya though. Slide into my DM's if you're interested. Ignore the stuff to the left hand side of the pic.
Edit: postage to dublin is crazy. fuck brexit. These need to be moved on, if anyone else is interested.
-
• #74
Spent some time tweaking the design of my fixture and have ordered the extrusions, plates and hardware needed to start building. It's broadly a copy of the Cobra Creator, modified so that I can make it with just a lathe, saw and pillar drill.
1 Attachment
-
• #75
Awesome, looks great. What are you using for the plates?
Only thing i would suggest is make the dummy axle holding section release horizontally, so you can slide that assembly back out of the way without moving the frame or the bb height once its tacked together. Looks awesome tho. Also if you have bikecad there is already dimensions built into the software to setup a vertical headtube jig, i did not know this and spent ages making a spreadsheet to do all the trigonometry before i realised.
Found some time for dicking around in CAD, came up with this seattube beam fixture, with one on both sides it'd be bolted down with 6 clamps which might be a bit over the top. I priced it up in the calculator of fractory.com and 3 sets (2 of the seattube plates and 4 of the sliding plates each) would be 100 GBP. Not too bad?
Couldn't be arsed to draw up the rest properly as I think your plan is perfect, only thing I'm unsure about is the dummy axle clamping situation, but would also depend on the axles used.
1 Attachment