You are reading a single comment by @Netakure and its replies.
Click here to read the full conversation.
-
I like how this post covers over subjects like how much is too much a tire for gravel or at what point having drops makes no sense.
Netakure-
Or how much tyre is too much for a drop bar? Maybe better if I'd said 'traditional/common drop bar uses' rather than where drops makes sense ie makes sense to me.
For tyres, let's assume gravel to fast XC tread and volume on either size rim. I might go a bit bigger on a 29er as I'm on that route to more technical ability but the point's valid if you assume general 650B gravel tyre or 29er XC tyre.
All I'm getting at is how these things add up and a bike can have parts that pull in a direction or gives the bike a useful bias. But if a drop-bar fat bike makes someone happy, all good and no logic needed.
jameso
I'll nerd-bite.. A 29er wheel has about 7% more OD than 650B, more stuff at the edge, it'll weigh about 7% more. The only thing that matters is the weight since the bigger wheel rotates slower at a given speed. 7% isn't enough for me to care tbh as wheels affect more important things when it comes to off-road riding.
My take on it seems to be about bump frequency and amplitude. Frequency is handled by volume, amplitude is handled by OD and roll-over. 650B is great for a road-gravel bike as it's got the volume potential at a lower weight, works well on fast, small bumps. 29ers can handle both so they make more sense for an XC MTB.
I like 650 x 50 for road and light gravel, basically anything where drop bars make sense. Another benefit to 650B as Ed said is you can get guards in and still have a fairly agile road geometry.
When the bumps get bigger and chunkier I'd go 29" but I'd also drop the drops by then, it's XC MTB time and I'd rather use an Jones bar or some sort of MTB bar than drops. With the wheel capability comes the want to handle the bike differently, for me anyway.
A 29" drop-bar like the Cutthroat could be good if you have a lot of that middle ground riding, neither road/gravel nor XC MTB. Most of my riding is more one or the other or I prefer a bike that has clear advantages and disadvantages vs something in that middle ground.