• For the c. 80% of the population who aren't Vitamin D deficient, yes, it is absolutely irrelevant. For the remainder, no, Vitamin D supplements might help. But as @Chalfie correctly notes, that doesn't make it a panacea which makes all problems go away.

  • I don't think anybody would think it was a panacea, but tbh living with this existential threat is something that might be helped by taking a vitamin that I woukd suspect more than 20% of people in this country are deficient in. Particularly following our dark winters. Doing something that might support a stronger immune system is worthwhile imo, and handwashing, and behaving in such a way that assumes you are infectious. The fluffy wooly guidance by the government is in sharp contrast to the 'get brexit done' message of the election. Which can only heighten anxiety

  • The stats say 20% of adults have some degree of Vitamin D deficiency, dark winters and all. When it comes to evidence-led advice, I'd prefer to rely on statistics than gut reaction and instinct. Of those, a percentage will have their immune systems improved by a significant extent by taking Vitamin D supplements. Of that smaller percentage, a still smaller percentage will find their recovery from Covid19 improved by taking supplements. Sure, it won't hurt taking them, but in the grand scheme of things it's a long way down the list of risk factors. Which is exactly the original point.

  • But you make it sound like it's specific to the virus. Plz don't spread false information. Its for those that have a deficiency to make them slightly healthier.

    Next we're going to hear VIT D CURES CORONA

About

Avatar for moorhen @moorhen started