You are reading a single comment by @Drano and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • I'm about as "in-group" as you could get, so it's hard for me to comment.

    But do you think that the greatest impact to minorities' daily lives is acceptance by wider society or attack by marginal extremes?

    Also in fairness to Festerban it's the idea that hate speech laws decrease hate that needs evidence, not the other way around.

  • Not sure if I understand the question, wider society makes a greater daily impact but both need to be addressed. Certain minorities are under constant attack from the press and institutions, and that spills over into daily life in the form of verbal or physical abuse from strangers.

    Also in fairness to Festerban it's the idea that hate speech laws decrease hate that needs evidence, not the other way around.

    The phrasing of that statement is kinda vague, but surely there's evidence of this sort of measure being effective: Germany's hard stance on Nazi speech online and offline, Milo Yiannopoulos and Alex Jones getting deplatformed, prosecutions in the UK for inciting violence against muslims, etc.

    Usually the people crying out against their free speech being infringed upon are really just upset because they can no longer express their hatred for minorities loudly and with impunity.

  • Usually the people crying out against their free speech being infringed upon are really just upset because they can no longer express their hatred for minorities loudly and with impunity.

    Care to make that statement a bit more sweeping?

  • Certain minorities are under constant attack from the press and institutions, and that spills over into daily life in the form of verbal or physical abuse from strangers.

    But the press and institutions aren't likely to be affected by hate laws.

    surely there's evidence of this sort of measure being effective:

    I'm just pulling you up on who needed to provide a citation. I'd be really interested to know.

    Usually the people crying out against their free speech being infringed upon are really just upset because they can no longer express their hatred for minorities loudly and with impunity.

    That is an awful generalisation that I'll put down to poor phrasing. But I agree that people who often complain "that you can't say x anymore", when you can, and often they literally are, but they're just being called out on it, fit your example.

About

Avatar for Drano @Drano started