You are reading a single comment by @Arducius and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • I think trailing edge is generally best with the current crop of GU10. It's the lower voltage range of the dimmer that is too high if it's not specifically for led's. Given that 6x5w leds makes 30w and a dimmer designed to work with halogen would have a lower range roughly equivalent to 1 halogen bulb, so 40w or practically 50w. The x-pro dimmers are programmable so you can set a lowest and highest limit, just buy the module for £10 and fit it to the existing plate with the existing knob.

    Another problem people have with bulbs blowing is caused by cheap bulbs. It's difficult to commit to buying a whole load of high quality GU10's if you've had a lot failing so you buy cheaper bulbs and they fail more regularly.

    Don't mix led and halogen on the same circuit, it can upset some dimmers and cause them to fail. It happens quite a bit in tenancies where leds are supplied but the tenant wants to fit the cheapest bulb. This is less of an issue now that prices are coming down.

    Try to get a bulb like Phillips master led from downlights.co.uk around £7 each, high cri and decent manufacturing quality.

    I'm not sure about wiring or 'quality' of mains supply having an effect although I hear it quite a bit from potential customers. Normally when I'm looking at the systems involved they have a lot of lights and they are not constantly replacing the same lamp!

    I guess that we've all heard the halogen bulbs buzzing when the filaments start to vibrate which usually means they will be giving out soon. Dimmer quality could have an effect on the filament I suppose. Wiring itself should be right or not with a variation of insulation resistance which would seem unlikely to play any part in the life of a bulb.

    There are some issues that arise with the connectors in the 12v halogen variety, sometimes when you change the bulb the problem of the connection goes away for a while but the old bulb is still fine, it's just that if it's stopped working you don't test it generally.

  • There are some issues that arise with the connectors in the 12v halogen variety, sometimes when you change the bulb the problem of the connection goes away for a while but the old bulb is still fine, it's just that if it's stopped working you don't test it generally.

    This appears to be my problem. Will better connectors likely help?

  • Probably. I buy them in job lots from eBay and carry them in my toolbox. There used to be a UK manufacturer selling them.

    Mr_Sworld is right though, best way forward these days is taking out the transformers, fitting GU10 connectors and GU10 leds. It has been a while coming but the quality is there at a reasonable price now.

    When I have a customer with a faulty 12v halogen I don't like to be that guy who suggests replacing all the bulbs is the only way forward though!

    Even the integrated downlighters are well worth consideration. Some have incredibly low profiles which means you can fit them where you couldn't have before. Then there's led strip which gives massive possibilities.

About

Avatar for Arducius @Arducius started