You are reading a single comment by @hippy and its replies.
Click here to read the full conversation.
-
What would be useful is if someone has done a study to see at what rate fat and carbs are burned at different exercise intensities.
I'm sure I've seen graphs of that. Gas masks...
I can't find the one I'm thinking of, it's a bar chart
hippy-
I'd need to see the data behind that graph as just the relative comparison doesn't tell anyone if the number of calories obtained from burning fat is staying the same, increasing or decreasing as intensity increases.
Going back to my made up figures:-
- lower intensity you burn 100kcal/hr from fat and 100kcal/hr from carbs
- a higher intensity you burn 120kcal/hr from fat and 130kcal/hr from carbs
Those numbers give a decrease in the relative contribution from fat, but an actual increase in absolute contribution from fat.
- lower intensity you burn 100kcal/hr from fat and 100kcal/hr from carbs
Greenbank
"burn a higher % of fat" was the big bit they all misunderstood and ran off in the wrong direction with, e.g. if (made up numbers) at:-
then lower intensity is not "better" just because you get 50% of energy from burning fat compared to 48% at higher intensity. With these made up figures you burn more fat at the higher intensity, not where the best percentage lies.
But if at lower intensity you burn x fat and y carbs and then at a higher intensity you burn the same amount of fat (x) but 1.5y carbs then there's no huge benefit looking at just the session alone (post exercise effects are another matter) since you end up burning the same amount of fat either way.
(Further effects would be that the higher intensity session should improve your overall CV fitness more, barring overtraining, so that you'll probably be even more efficient for future sessions which could lead to more fat burn, etc. It's going to be very complex.)
What would be useful is if someone has done a study to see at what rate fat and carbs are burned at different exercise intensities.
If fat burn increases slightly at higher intensities then all the better to go out and smash it, but if the body starts to burn less fat (and more and more carbs) at higher intensities then smashing it might not be so beneficial.
No idea how they'd actually measure that though, probably #magnets