I ran my last daily bike with a chain guard (SKS Chainboard), which attaches via a bracket that's clamped between the drive side BB cup and the frame. That bike had a square taper BB and that never caused any issues (after I had tightened it up properly). My new daily bike has external BB cups (Hollowtech 2) and I've been advised that it's a bad idea having that type of fixing because there is a risk that the BB cups (and therefore bearings) will end up not being coaxial, which would lead to greater bearing wear and possibly early failure.
I ran my last daily bike with a chain guard (SKS Chainboard), which attaches via a bracket that's clamped between the drive side BB cup and the frame. That bike had a square taper BB and that never caused any issues (after I had tightened it up properly). My new daily bike has external BB cups (Hollowtech 2) and I've been advised that it's a bad idea having that type of fixing because there is a risk that the BB cups (and therefore bearings) will end up not being coaxial, which would lead to greater bearing wear and possibly early failure.
Is that true?