You are reading a single comment by @HousecatHST and its replies.
Click here to read the full conversation.
-
support of the Palestinian cause
I’m sure @punkture will be along shortly to point out that that in itself is often anitsemitism.
The problem with all this is exactly what @Batt said
"Zionist" is not a term that has its roots in hatred, which has then been reclaimed by the community but remains taboo outside it (unlike the word that "niggardly" sounds like). It's a word that originated within the Jewish community and has been in use ever since. Just recently, Benjamin Netanyahu referred to the passing of the controverisal nation-state law as "a defining moment in the annals of Zionism". Given that Zionism is therefore a perfectly valid and specific political description and that not all Jews are Zionists and not all Zionists are Jews, we need a new term that is exactly equivalent to "Zionist".
The problem is that in the absence of an offering of a new word for "Zionist" it's very hard to see criticisim of its use in this case as anything other than a means of shutting down a valid debate.
Corbyn's stance on racism has been absolutely consistent as has his stance on apartheid, which is a term that has increasingly been used to describe Israel's stance. Contrary to what @h2o quoted his actions suggest that he's completed uninterested in a political fix but rather that he's being completely consistent with his previous support of the Palestinian cause.