You are reading a single comment by @NurseHolliday and its replies.
Click here to read the full conversation.
-
The thing, is what's the point? From my basically luddite perspective, unless the watch objectively fails at telling the time, the rest of it is just personal taste.
What sort of criticism would you offer in reviews?
NurseHolliday-
Plenty of scope for subjective reviews. Aesthetic balance, proportion. Innovation, history, new manufacturing methods etc.
Not really any different from reviewing clothing, after all clothes from Primark serve their primary purpose just as well as those from Prada but that doesn't stop people from having opinions.
danb
Makes me wonder if there would be demand for a genuinely critical watch review site. Then again, the manufacturers would never send you their watches for review.