You are reading a single comment by @pifko and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • I agree with the thermal conductivity thing (people get hypothermic and die much quicker in cold water) but I don't know enough physics to dispute the idea about the calories. What I will suggest though is that at a high work rate, humans are producing a fuck load of heat, so exercising in water is 'maybe' more efficient since your body doesn't need to work so hard to cool down? Also, there's bouyancy in water, so you're moving but body weight is part suspended. So you're working to go forward but not support yourself, like say, running. Need a proper scientist to answer this. I hate swimming though, unless I'm chasing a can of beer down a river...

  • However there’s a great big load of water providing resistance in all directions(?), which running does not have.

    Can you tell I was shit at science in school?

  • Yeah, but you're gliding through it. Wait, this is a different thing. We want to know if more calories are lost due to thermal conductivity of water, not just the activity.

About

Avatar for pifko @pifko started