You are reading a single comment by @skydancer and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • I agree in principle that mutilating a baby's body for whatever reason is unacceptable, and perfectly understand people's arguments about denying choice by imposing this at a very young age. Especially since I have no-religious belief at all.

    However, I do come from a culturally Jewish background. Some close members of my family are orthodox Jews. I can also completely see their view that circumcising a son is a core fundamental practice, rational or not, hygienic or not. An uncircumcised Jewish boy is anathema and extremely problematic.

  • An uncircumcised Jewish boy is anathema and extremely problematic.

    Forgive me, but in what way is a Jewish (or any other faith) infant / boy an anathema and extremely problematic.
    In what way is any infant problematic? (Other than the pee, poo and noise)

About

Avatar for skydancer @skydancer started