You are reading a single comment by @Charlie_L and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • Hive, Wiser or What?

    We have been around this question before but it would be good to get updated advice on choices and people's experiences.

    • I want remote control of the heating, and possibly hot water.
    • The use is extremely random with no regular leave or arrive times
    • The thermostat should be moveable, battery powered because when the woodburner is going we have to move the stat away.
    • I don't want geofencing. That would require a phone to be active all the time - also we may approach the house on foot, bike, car, train+bike or ferry+bike. The train and ferry options bring us within 2 miles of the house before stopping further away. Basically I don't think any geofencing can help.

    The options seem to be:
    Hive
    Netatmo
    Honeywell Lyric wireless model
    Drayton Wiser multizone 2

    The Drayton seems attractive, it fits over existing wiring and if I buy rad thermostats later it can give room zoning effect and react to wood burners being on or off.
    As far as I can see Nest and Tado require a hard wired thermostat which I don't want.

  • Tado require a hard wired thermostat which I don't want.

    The Tado thermostat also runs on battery - I don't have it wired in. It communicates with a receiver that is wired to the boiler. You don't have to use the geofencing if you don't want to.

    Your heating & hot water setup will determine which ones you can use too.

    I've used Hive on a combi, and it's pretty straight forward.

    Netatmo's customer support is utterly clueless. Tado's is the opposite, and some of the best customer support I've ever encountered.

  • Nest doesn't have a battery powered thermostat, but does just have a plug you can just move around, so depends if you are willing to do that.

  • Netatmo isn't moveable, it's wired in in place of your existing thermostat. Simple to fit and cheap but a bit more basic than the others.

About

Avatar for Charlie_L @Charlie_L started