You are reading a single comment by @hamrack and its replies. Click here to read the full conversation.
  • Intuitively (ie guessing) a loading a domestic won't try to change the sign of the curvature, whereas loading a saddle will...?

    I'll take your word for it. I always find it tricky to think of saddles.

  • I always find it tricky to think of saddles.

    You're not alone! On re-engaging of my brain, loading a dome tries to flatten it i.e. movin from +ve curvature to 0 curvature. But, I think it depends how you load your structures. Good knows. Ask a (academic) structural engineer!

  • I'd assume loading both would make the curvature go to 0 as you'd be making the positive curve of the saddle flatten but only accentuating the negative curve. Can't imagine the negative curve bending to positive under loading (I know it can't but if that's our argument for saddles being stiffer...).

    Alas, I'm sure it'll be covered in due course.

About

Avatar for hamrack @hamrack started