You are reading a single comment by @spotter and its replies.
Click here to read the full conversation.
spotter-
Alpkit again. Pretty pleased for the price and custom nature of these things.
I tend to default their way as I'm always on a budget - too many bikes to keep going. To date, I've been pleased with everything. A friend however got the all singing and dancing saddle pack and that just looked like a dogs dinner. Way too complicated and less ability to just bodge it on like the simple one. Was't cheap either.
Scrabble
All a bit stashed away at the moment so hard to get pics. I didn't do anything too precise. Just cut some flexible relatively thin plastic into a liner kind of shape and put it in the bag so it supports the bottom side. The different strap is just an obvious upgrade I think. It's all about tension with these things and a proper clasp is loads easier to get tight.
Mine also tends to be more up the seatpost than stuck way out the back. The further past the back of saddle it goes, the more likely its going to swing IME.
Here it is in setup mode - excuse the straps that need tucking away...
