Are you using a torque wrench?
Threadlok and 50 nm might be worth a try.
I have to admit, no I am not using a torque wrench.
It looks the spindle has bitten into the crank the wrong way and it's a bin job :/
I could try to file it a little and threadlok, but chance of success are low. I guess i've nothing to lose...
Since it's a non driveside crank arm, bin it and get another 170mm diamond one.
40 nm is recommended for most square taper cranks. It is more than you would think. Buy a new crank and find someone with a torque wrench.
Edit after spotting photo upthread.
The damage to the inside of the taper is from your dodgy crank puller. I reckon that crank will stay on fine.
@JWestland started
London Fixed Gear and Single-Speed is a community of predominantly fixed gear and single-speed cyclists in and around London, UK.
This site is supported almost exclusively by donations. Please consider donating a small amount regularly.
Are you using a torque wrench?
Threadlok and 50 nm might be worth a try.