You are reading a single comment by @edscoble and its replies.
Click here to read the full conversation.
-
The Stack and Reach to me revolutionised bike fitting, however you're right about this; the seat angle will need to be taken in account as the massive frames tend to be slacker that the majority of customers end up with their saddle set far forward even with an on-line post.
Ditto to small frame with steep seat tube, massive set back needed.
What did you parents feed you!??
Kidding. I used to think Stack and Reach was a great way of sizing frames...but when you dig in to it I think it falls down when the angles change across sizes. Maybe.
I think particularly large or small riders, or riders with 'shapes' that aren't typical of their gender need to sling themselves over possible contenders as the numbers don't really work for them.